home sales rentals construction contact us Fire Island guide
 

Fire Island Homes for Sale

Fire Island has a reputation as a summer vacation spot, but Fire Island homes and Fire Island houses available for rental feature the type of privacy, exclusivity, versatility and comfort that make them wonderful places to live year-round, for half a year, or just for a few weeks. William J. Newman Realty has numerous Fire Island homes for sale or rent and we’re eager to put you in touch with our Fire Island sales department to see if we can find the right place for you to call home – for as long as you like.

Servicing Fire Island’s western communities since 1969, we offer the experience and professionalism to help you in your hunt for Fire Island homes in the neighborhood of your choice. We specialize in sales and rentals from Fair Harbor to Dunewood, Lonelyville, Saltaire and Kismet.

Available year-round seven days a week, our six associates provide an unmatched expertise, service and dedication in finding Fire Island houses for sale or rent. With over 40 years experience in Fire Island real estate, we can offer you full service - including construction of additions or new home construction - to meet all your Fire Island real estate needs. Our two Fire Island offices are located in Fair Harbor at the ferry dock and across from Le Dock restaurant.

 
 
 

Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref ID: S054

This is the definition of a charming beach cottage in Fair Harbor. The 3 bedrooms are spacious with convenient built in closets. The kitchen was recently renovated and opens out to a comfortable living space. Vaulted ceilings in the living space and lots of windows make for bright summer days. Multiple deck areas are great for entertaining or just lounging in the sun. The full bath is a great size and there is also a private outdoor shower. This cottage is one off the bay on one of Fair Harbors nicest walks with convenient proximity to town. This is an excellent house at an excellent price.

Offered at $620,000

*View photo gallery  
 
 
 
   
 
 

Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref ID: S051

Exclusive Listing

Spectacular ocean front home with 3 bedrooms and 1.5 baths. Great layout with open kitchen/living room area. Designed to have beautiful ocean views from all rooms. Master bedroom with bath and large sliding glass door that opens out to decking. Vaulted ceilings and large windows provide great architecture and lighting in the living area. Convenient laundry room with access from inside and outside the home. Located on desirable walk close to town.

Offered at $1,200,000

*View photo gallery  
 
 
 
   
 
 

Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref ID: S052

Exclusive Listing

This beach home boasts 5 large bedrooms and 2 full baths. Extremely spacious inside and out with 4 decking areas. Roof top deck has partial bay and ocean views. Inside the first level has a large kitchen that is opened out to a comfortable living space and dining room. 2 bedrooms and 1 bath are just off the living area. The second level has 3 bedrooms and 1 bath. Landscaping gives the house very nice privacy on front and rear decking areas. This home is centrally located giving it easy access to town area and also great proximity to the beach.

Offered at $715,000

*View photo gallery  
 
 
 
   
 
 

Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref ID: S053

Charming beach cottage with 3 bedrooms and 1.5 baths. Located close to the bay on a very quiet walk. The kitchen opens out to a large living area and the 2 spaces are brought together by a nice bar height counter. There is a full bath off the kitchen and 2 spacious bedrooms off the living area. The second floor has a bedroom and half bath. There is also a large unfinished space with great potential on the second floor. The outside space has great decking and a rear yard that is very private. This house is priced to sell.

Offered at $650,000

*View photo gallery  
*See this location on map  
 
 
   
 
 

Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref ID: S050

Exclusive Listing

Development Opportunity: This is a 4 lot parcel one off the bay on a beautiful Fair Harbor walk. Architectural plans available for a gorgeous bay view home. DEC and BOH permits in hand. Call or E-Mail for further details.

Offered at $765,000

*View photo gallery  
 
 
 
   
 
 

Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref ID: S039

This 4 bedroom 2.5 bath has a great layout and great square footage. The 4 bedrooms are located on the first floor with 2 full bathrooms. There is a living space on the first level with a pool table. The upper level is one open room with living, dinning and kitchen. Vaulted ceilings and large windows make a the large space even bigger and it also has great bay views. With 2 large upper decks there is plenty of space to enjoy the sun. This is a special, unique house.

Offered at $1,000,000

*View photo gallery  
*See this location on map  
 
 
   
 
 

Dunewood, Fire Island
Ref ID: S048

This turn-key Dunewood beach home is in an excellent location. It has 3 spacious bedrooms and 2 full baths. There is an open kithen/living room layout with great light coming through 2 large skylights. The living room has 2 sliding doors that open out to a beautiful fully screened in porch. There is a large deck area with built in benches as well as a roof top deck. Surrounding landscape make this house completely private. Great proximity to bay, beach and tennis courts.

Offered at $795,000

*View photo gallery  
*See this location on map  
 
 
   
 
 

Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref ID: S041

If you are looking for cozy and simple beach living look no further. This 3 bed 1 bath is in close proximity to the ocean, bay and town. Classic fire island design with exposed beams on a vaulted ceiling. There are ceiling fans throughout and there is no trouble staying cool in this house. Nice sized back deck and outdoor shower. Large bathroom conveniently located right off back deck.

Reduced Price $579,000!

*View photo gallery  
*See this location on map  
 
 
   
 
 

Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref ID: S030

This 4 bedroom 2.5 bath has endless indoor and outdoor space. With 2 living areas you have room for plenty of guests in this summer retreat. Enjoy even more space with wraparound, multilevel decking. The bedrooms are very spacious with 3 located on the first floor and 1 on the second floor. There is a master suite with a full bath and its own entrance from the rear deck. The kitchen is large and nicely open to living area.

Reduced price $725,000

*View photo gallery  
*See this location on map  
 
 
   
 
 

Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref ID: S047

Development Opportunity. This is a large parcel of land with a small 2 bedroom cottage. There are 12 lots in total. The southern end has a 2 bedroom, 1 bath cottage and the northern end is vacant land. This property is on East walk in Saltaire and borders Fair Harbor. 2 large houses can be built or a house with a swimming pool.

Offered at $3,000,000

   
   
 
 
 
   
 
 

Saltaire, Fire Island
Ref ID: S038

This is a unique summer home that comes with 2 guest cottages. The main house has been renovated and has 2 bedrooms and 1 bath. There is a new kitchen and also a fireplace in the living room. The larger guest cottage has its own full bath and a nice sitting area to enjoy morning paper. The second cottage is not much smaller with a ½ bath of its own. This unique property is located on a beach access walk and is very close to the ocean.

Reduced Price $795,000

*View photo gallery  
*See this location on map  
 
 
   
 
 

Saltaire, Fire Island
Ref ID: S035

You don’t get much quieter than this location on a private non though walk. Nestled in the trees this large 4 bedroom 2 bath was recently renovated and is in mint condition. Large upper decking provides a partial bay view. Inside the bedrooms are very large and very comfortable. The kitchen is open to the living space which has a very nice fireplace.

Reduced price $1,095,000

*View photo gallery  
*See this location on map  
 
 
   
 
 

Saltaire, Fire Island
Ref ID: S045

This Saltaire property provides a rare opportunity with approval given to expand on its 7 lots. Already a spacious 4 bedroom 2 bath this house has tons of potential. Located on a very quiet walk made extremely private by surrounding nature. The property gets great sunlight and is just 1 block away from a beach access walk.

E-mail for more details!

*View photo gallery  
*See this location on map  
 
 
   
 
 

Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref ID: R039

This Fire Island home has 3 bedrooms and 1.5 baths. It is very spacious with large bedrooms not typical for a Fire Island house. There is a great brick fireplace in the living/dining room. Large windows and sliding glass doors provide excellent natural lighting. Wood floors go throughout the house. There are large decks in addition to a great yard. Fully winterized on a large 5 lot parcel this beach home is a great opportunity.

SOLD BY WILLIAM J NEWMAN REALTY

*View photo gallery  
*See this location on map  
 
 
   
 
 

Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref ID: R032

Located close to the bay this very large 3 bedroom 2 bath home gets great summer breezes. This is a split level house with a master suit with full bath on the 3rd level. There is a deck outside the master with bay views. An open kitchen and living area are on the mid level with a fire place. The final 2 bedrooms and bath are on the first level. A multilevel deck provides plenty of space and gets lots of sun. A great house with great location it is a must see!

Reduced price $825,000

*View photo gallery  
*See this location on map  
 
 
   
 
 

Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref ID: R029

SOLD BY WILLIAM J NEWMAN REALTY

*View photo gallery  
*See this location on map  
 
 
   
 
 

Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref ID: S022

SOLD BY WILLIAM J NEWMAN REALTY

*View photo gallery  
*See this location on map  
 
 
   
 
 

Lonelyville, Fire Island
Ref ID: S027

SOLD BY WILLIAM J NEWMAN REALTY

*View photo gallery  
*See this location on map  
 
 
   
 
 

Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref ID: S042

SOLD BY WILLIAM J NEWMAN REALTY

*View photo gallery  
*See this location on map  
 
 
   
 
 

Ref ID: S034

SOLD BY WILLIAM J NEWMAN REALTY

*View photo gallery  
*See this location on map  
 
 
   
 
 

Ref ID: S044

SOLD BY WILLIAM J NEWMAN REALTY

*View photo gallery  
*See this location on map  
 
 
   
 
 

Ref ID: S040

SOLD BY WILLIAM J NEWMAN REALTY

*View photo gallery  
*See this location on map  
 
 
   
 
 

Ref ID: S032

SOLD BY WILLIAM J NEWMAN REALTY

*View photo gallery  
*See this location on map