631.312.7066 or 516.991.5717

William J. Newman Realty

Why Rent with Newman Realty?

William J. Newman has over 40 years of Fire Islands west end. With 6 assoicates with are available 7 days a week to answer questions or help with any issues that arise during your stay. We offer free delivery of your luggage and freight when moving into your rental making the move in process as easy as possible.

Search Results

Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R174
$6,500 per week
4 Beds
3 Baths
Location: 3rd from the beach
Beautiful and private just steps to the ocean
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R173
3 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Bay side
Clean and comfortable cottage with central AC
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R172
$5,500 per week
3 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Bay Side
Well maintained and private
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R171
$5,750 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Immaculate upside down house
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R170
$10,000 per week
5 Beds
2.5 Baths
Location: Bay Front
Amazing bay and sunset views
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R169
$4,500 per week
5 Beds
2 Baths
Location Bay Side
Spacious beach house with renovated kitchen
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Lonelyville, Fire Island
Ref #: R168
$4,500 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Steps to the beach and the bay
Clean and updated beach house
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Lonelyville, Fire Island
Ref #: R167
4 Beds
3.5 Baths
Ocean Front
Magnificent open layout with views from every room
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2024 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R166
$5,000 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Spacious 3 bedroom 1.5 bath
Open layout great for entertaining
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor.Fire Island
Ref #: R165
$7,000 per week
4 Beds
2.5 Baths
Beautiful fully renovated traditional beach house
Extremely private bay side location
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R164
$5,500 per week
4 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay side close to the beach
Large open layout with vaulted ceilings
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2024 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R163
$5,500 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Modernist gem designed by noted architect Horace Gifford
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R103
$4,900 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
1 off the beach with ocean views
Beautifully renovated and meticulously cared for
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R162
$4,250 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Beautiful beach cottage very well maintained
Renovated kitchen and baths
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R161
$6,000 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Amazing architectural house
Bay side on quiet walk
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty Exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R044
$4,500 per week
3 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Bay side
Beautifully detailed and decorated
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2025 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor,Fire Island
Ref #: R159
$8,000 per week
4 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Ocean front
Beautiful house with rooftop deck and panoramic views
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Lonelyville, Fire Island
Ref #: R158
$5,250 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Ocean front
Simple relaxing island living
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R157
$4,500 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Renovated with new kitchen and bathrooms
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2024 Newman Realty Exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R011
$3,500 per week
2 Beds
1 Baths
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty Exclusive
Ref #: R156
$4,000 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay Side
Clean and comfortable with AC
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2024 availability
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R131
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Ocean Side
Bright immaculate beach house
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R155
$4,000 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Simple spacious beach cottage
View Property
Property Status: SOLD!!-Listed Exclusively with William Newman Realty
Ref #: S123
4 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Ocean Side
4 bedroom on large property
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty Exclusive
Lonelyville, Fire Island
Ref #: R154
$6,000 per week
5 Beds
2.5 Baths
Location: Close to the ocean
Beautifully renovated 5 bedroom
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2025 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor,Fire Island
Ref #: R153
$6,000 per week
4 Beds
2 Baths
Location: 1 off ocean
Mint ocean view cottage
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty Exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R152
4 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Ocean front
Spacious with amazing views
View Property
Property Status: For Rent
Before and After
View Property
Property Status: Email for availability 2024 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R151
$4,500 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Bay Side
Renovated on quiet walk
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2022
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R150
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Charming with great privacy
Location: Bay side
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R149
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Ocean front
Mid century modern with amazing views
View Property
Bathroom Renovations
View Property
Exterior Renovations
View Property
Kitchen Renovations
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2019 Newman Realty exclusive
Lonelyville, Fire Island
Ref #: R147
$10,000 per week
4 Beds
2.5 Baths
Magnificent ocean front
Ocean views from every room
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R146
$5,500 per week
4 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Ocean Side
Clean house on private property
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor
Ref #: R144
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay Side
Clean and simple with great location
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2021 availability Newman Realty Exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R145
$3,000 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Bay side
Meticulously cared for beach cottage
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2019
Lonelyville, Fire Island
Ref #: R143
$4,000 per week
3 Beds
3 Baths
Location: 1 off ocean
Amazing ocean views
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2019
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R142
$4,000 per week
4 Beds
1.5 Baths
Private back deck
Bay view
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R141
$9,000 per week
4 Beds
3 Baths
Location: Ocean front
Brand new construction triple mint full amenities
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2022
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R140
$4,000 per week
3 Beds
2 Baths
Location: 3rd from Ocean
Spacious 2 story with open layout
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R139
$6,000 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: 1 off the beach with amazing ocean views
Triple mint fully renovated
View Property
Property Status: Rented 2024 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R022
$5,000 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Clean comfortable charming cottage
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2025 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R015
$7,500 per week
5 Beds
2.5 Baths
Location: Bay side with bay views
Triple mint new construction
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2019
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R065
$4,500 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
Locaton: Ocean side
Great ocean views
View Property
Property Status: New ocean front construction completed on schedule in 2017
Fair Harbor, Fire Island--New ocean front construction led by project manager John Riley
Ref #: C004
3 Beds
2 Baths
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty Exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R160
$5,600 per week
3 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Bay Front
Amazing views of the Great South Bay and Robert Moses Bridge
View Property
Property Status: New construction designed and built 2017
Fair Harbor, Fire Island--New construction with bay views designed by John Riley
Ref #: C003
4 Beds
2.5 Baths
Beautiful bay side beach house with design that captures bay views
Designed with 10 ft ceilings throughout for open airy feel
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2019 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R137
$4,000 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Ocean side
4 from ocean with ocean views
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2018 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R136
$4,000 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
Beautiful private beach house
Great location on quiet walk
View Property
Property Status: Email for availability 2022 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R072
$4,500 per week
3 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Bay side
Wonderful beachy feel and freshly updated
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2024 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R130
$5,000 per week
4 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
The perfect beach rental with every detail you could need
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2021 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R135
$4,000 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Ocean side
Amazing traditional Fair Harbor house
View Property
Property Status: Available 7/6-7/13 for 2018
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R038
$4,000 per week
5 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Bay front
Amazing bay views right in front of you
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R086
$5,000 per week
4 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Bay side
Beautifully renovated beach home
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2024
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R013
$6,100 per week
4 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Bay front
Bay views from upper and lower decks
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2019 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R016
$5,000 per week
4 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Bay side
1 off the bay with bay views
View Property
Property Status: Rented 2019
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R028
$4,500 per week
4 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Bay side
Big traditional with huge decks on large property
View Property
Property Status: New construction designed and built in 2010
Fair Harbor, Fire Island new construction with ocean views and pool designed by John Riley
Ref #: C002
4 Beds
2.5 Baths
Contemporary 1 off the ocean with tremendous views
Fantastic design to optimize ocean views and air flow
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2025 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R012
$6,500 per week
4 Beds
2.5 Baths
Location: Ocean side
4 houses from the ocean with ocean views from rooftop deck
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2021 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R134
$6,000 per week
5 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Ocean side
Spacious multilevel house with fantastic location
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R133
$6,500 per week
4 Beds
3.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Immaculate architectural house
View Property
Property Status: Available June/September 2025 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R024
$6,500 per week
4 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Ocean side
Great renovated house on quiet walk 6 from ocean
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2024
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R045
$7,250 per week
4 Beds
2.5 Baths
Location: Ocean side
1 off the ocean with ocean views
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2019
Lonelyville, Fire Island
Ref #: R046
$4,000 per week
4 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Ocean side
Huge back deck space
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R049
$7,250 per week
4 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Bay front
Cove views from upper deck and sunset views
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2024 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R050
$5,000 per week
4 Beds
3 Baths
Location: Bay side
Guest house with 5th bedroom
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R051
$5,500 per week
4 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Bay side
Solid beach rental with everything you could need
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2019 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R053
$5,000 per week
4 Beds
2.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
One off the bay with fantastic water views
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 201 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R054
$5,000 per week
4 Beds
2 Baths
Bay side
Triple mint with expansive front and rear decks
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2024 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R055
$5,000 per week
4 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Ocean side
3rd from ocean great easy beach house
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2019 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R060
$4,500 per week
4 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Bay side
Upside down house surrounded by nature
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2019 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R064
$6,000 per week
4 Beds
2.5 Baths
Locaton: Bay side
Sweeping island views and 3 levels of decking
View Property
Property Status: Rented 2024 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R083
$6,000 per week
5 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Bay side
Beautiful traditional beach house with room for everyone
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2021 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R079
$4,500 per week
4 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Bay side
Tranquil rooftop deck getaway
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Lonelyville, Fire Island
Ref #: R088
$5,000 per week
4 Beds
3 Baths
Location: Ocean side
Mint with 3 deck areas and close to the ocean
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2019
Dunewood, Fire Island
Ref #: R092
$4,500 per week
4 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Gorgeous beach home with great deck space
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2018 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R096
$5,000 per week
4 Beds
2.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Spacious with air conditioning
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2019
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R095
$8,000 per week
4 Beds
2.5 Baths
Location: Ocean front
Panoramic ocean and bay views
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R097
$6,500 per week
4 Beds
2.5 Baths
Location: Bay front
Amazing water and sunset views
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2019
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R099
$4,500 per week
4 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Bay side
Back deck is a secluded getaway
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R021
$7,250 per week
5 Beds
2.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Pristine secluded beach house
View Property
Property Status: email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R104
$6,000 per week
4 Beds
2.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Spacious with 2 living rooms and large bedrooms
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2019
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R112
$5,000 per week
4 Beds
2 Baths
Location:Bay side
One off the bay with great bay views
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2025 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R115
$6,000 per week
4 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Fully renovated and super comfortable
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2019 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R125
$5,000 per week
4 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Bay side
Beautiful house with great layout
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R128
$4,000 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Great upper deck space
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R033
$4,250 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Fully renovated immaculate cottage
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2025 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R027
$6,000 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Ocean side
4th from ocean exquisite house
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2020
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R008
$4,000 per week
3 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Bay side
Extremely private with large decking
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R032
$6,000 per week
3 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Bay side
One off the bay with bay views
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2019
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R035
$3,500 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Generous space inside and out
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R019
$6,000 per week
3 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Ocean side
Amazing house 1 off ocean with spectacular views
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2019 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R039
$4,000 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Large private property with new decking
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2019 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R048
$5,000 per week
3 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Bay side
Spacious split level with bright open living area
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2018 Availability
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R034
$4,000 per week
3 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Bay front
Beautiful views from large living room with large sliders
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R058
$4,400 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Exquisite 2 bedroom with guest house
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2019 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R068
$5,500 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Ocean front
Enormous front and side decks
View Property
Property Status: Email for availability 2022 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Lonelyville, Fire Island
Ref #: R073
$4,000 per week
3 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Bay front
Amazing bay views and sunset views
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2019 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R082
$3,500 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Fully renovated beautiful home
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R061
$5,000 per week
4 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Charming spacious beach cottage
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2019 Newman Realty exclusive
Lonelyville, Fire Island
Ref #: R081
$3,500 per week
3 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Ocean side
Tremendous ocean views and steps to the beach
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2019
Dunewood, Fire Island
Ref #: R036
$4,000 per week
3 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Bay side
Rooftop deck and screened in porch
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2019
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R102
$5,000 per week
3 Beds
2.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Architectural gem with huge guest house
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2019
Saltaire, Fire Island
Ref #: R105
$4,000 per week
3 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Bay side
Close to town and the beach
View Property
Property Status: "> Rented for 2017
Lonelyville, Fire Island
Ref #: R117
$4,000 per week
3 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Ocean side
4th from ocean with partial ocean view
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R121
$7,000 per week
4 Beds
3 Baths
Location: Ocean side
Beautiful immaculate home 4th from the beach
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2020
Lonelyville, Fire Island
Ref #: R113
$4,500 per week
3 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Bay side
Beautiful open house built by Newman construction
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R129
$9,000 per week
4 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Ocean front
Fully renovated amazing house
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2024 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R132
$4,000 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Bay side
Newly renovated beautiful beach house
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2024 availability
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R116
$4,000 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Bay side
New private expansive back deck
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2019 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R098
$3,500 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Ocean side
Open layout with great sunroom
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2019
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R026
$3,500 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Ocean side
Partial ocean view and steps to the beach
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2024 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R037
$5,000 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Ocean side
6th from the ocean with private back deck
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2023 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R093
$3,000 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Ocean side
4th from ocean with air conditioning
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2019
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R041
$4,000 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Ocean side
1 off the ocean with marvelous roof top deck
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R042
$4,000 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Bay side
1 off the bay with a great bay view
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2019
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R043
$3,500 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Ocean side
Quaint beach home with great location
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2019
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R020
$3,000 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Bay side
Charming comfortable cottage
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2024 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R067
$4,000 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Bay side
Perfect beach house for relaxing
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2024 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R071
$3,500 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Ocean side
Lovely super clean beach house
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R078
$3,500 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Bay side
Very private with oversized back deck
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2024 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R119
$4,000 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Bay side
Newly renovated with air conditioning
View Property
Property Status: Rented 2024
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R085
$4,000 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Bay side
Simple clean comfortable cottage
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2019 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R087
$3,500 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Bay side
View Property
Property Status: Rented 2024
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R017
$3,500 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Ocean side
Clean and cozy beach side cottage
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2019 Newman Realty exclusive
82 Holly Dr
Ref #: R118
Fair Harbor, NY, 11706
$3,250 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Ocean side
Newly renovated inside and out
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2020 availability
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R091
$3,000 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Ocean side
Privacy and close to the ocean
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2024 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R110
$4,500 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Bay side
Beautiful beach house
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2019 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R111
$3,500 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Ocean side
Clean and comfortable beach rental
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2024 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R122
$4,000 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Bay side
Classic Fair Harbor cottage
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R127
$4,000 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Ocean side
Third from ocean with partial ocean view
View Property
Property Status: Email for availability 2022 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R123
$3,500 per week
3 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Bay side
Charming 1920's cottage
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2019 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R120
$2,750 per week
2 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Bay side
Private location
View Property
Property Status: Rented For 2024
Fair Harbor,Fire Island
Ref #: R007
$4,000 per week
2 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay front
Beautiful bay views
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2024 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R005
$4,000 per week
3 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Bay side
Simple relaxing cottage
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2022 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R003
$6,500 per week
3 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Ocean side with ocean views
Newly renovated on large property with great privacy
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2024 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R074
$3,500 per week
2 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Ocean side
Very spacious back deck area set up for great outside dining
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2018
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R076
2 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Mint condition with guest cottage
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2022 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R080
$4,000 per week
2 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Ocean front
Unique rustic cottage
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2018 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R106
$2,750 per week
2 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Private outdoor deck and patio
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2024 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R047
$3,000 per week
2 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Bay side
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2022 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R124
4 Beds
3 Baths
1800 Sqft
Location: Ocean front
Full Amenities
Ocean views from all rooms
View Property
Property Status: Rented for 2025 Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R009
$4,500 per week
2 Beds
1 Baths
Ocean Front
Open with vaulted ceiling
View Property
Property Status: Renovated 2008
Fair Harbor, Fire Island Ocean Front Renovation designed by John Riley
Ref #: C001
4 Beds
2.5 Baths
2129 Sqft
Traditional meets contemporary
Ocean front designed with open floor plan
View Property