631.312.7066 or 516.991.5717

William J. Newman Realty

Why Rent with Newman Realty?

William J. Newman has over 40 years of Fire Islands west end. With 6 assoicates with are available 7 days a week to answer questions or help with any issues that arise during your stay. We offer free delivery of your luggage and freight when moving into your rental making the move in process as easy as possible.

Search Results

Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R174
$6,500 per week
4 Beds
3 Baths
Location: 3rd from the beach
Beautiful and private just steps to the ocean
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R173
$4,000 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Bay side
Clean and comfortable cottage
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R172
$5,500 per week
3 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Bay Side
Well maintained and private
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R171
$5,900 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Immaculate upside down house
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R170
$10,000 per week
5 Beds
2.5 Baths
Location: Bay Front
Amazing bay and sunset views
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R169
$5,000 per week
5 Beds
2 Baths
Location Bay Side
Spacious beach house with renovated kitchen
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Lonelyville, Fire Island
Ref #: R168
$4,500 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Steps to the beach and the bay
Clean and updated beach house
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Lonelyville, Fire Island
Ref #: R167
4 Beds
3.5 Baths
Ocean Front
Magnificent open layout with views from every room
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R166
$5,000 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Spacious 3 bedroom 1.5 bath
Open layout great for entertaining
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R164
$5,500 per week
4 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay side close to the beach
Large open layout with vaulted ceilings
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R163
$5,500 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Modernist gem designed by noted architect Horace Gifford
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R103
$4,900 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
1 off the beach with ocean views
Beautifully renovated and meticulously cared for
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R162
$4,500 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Beautiful beach cottage very well maintained
Renovated kitchen and baths
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R161
$6,000 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Amazing architectural house
Bay side on quiet walk
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R044
$5,000 per week
3 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Bay side
Beautifully detailed and decorated
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor,Fire Island
Ref #: R159
$8,000 per week
4 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Ocean front
Beautiful house with rooftop deck and panoramic views
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R157
$4,500 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Renovated with new kitchen and bathrooms
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R155
$4,500 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Simple spacious beach cottage
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Lonelyville, Fire Island
Ref #: R154
$6,000 per week
5 Beds
2.5 Baths
Location: Close to the ocean
Beautifully renovated 5 bedroom
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty Exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R152
4 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Ocean front
Spacious with amazing views
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor
Ref #: R144
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay Side
Clean and simple with great location
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R141
$9,000 per week
4 Beds
3 Baths
Location: Ocean front
Brand new construction triple mint full amenities
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R160
$5,600 per week
3 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Bay Front
Amazing views of the Great South Bay and Robert Moses Bridge
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R086
$5,000 per week
4 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Bay side
Beautifully renovated beach home
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R012
$6,500 per week
4 Beds
2.5 Baths
Location: Ocean side
4 houses from the ocean with ocean views from rooftop deck
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R133
$6,500 per week
4 Beds
3.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Immaculate architectural house
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R049
$7,250 per week
4 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Bay front
Cove views from upper deck and sunset views
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R051
$5,750 per week
4 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Bay side
Solid beach rental with everything you could need
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Lonelyville, Fire Island
Ref #: R088
$5,000 per week
4 Beds
3 Baths
Location: Ocean side
Mint with 3 deck areas and close to the ocean
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R097
$6,500 per week
4 Beds
2.5 Baths
Location: Bay front
Amazing water and sunset views
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R021
$7,500 per week
5 Beds
2.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Pristine secluded beach house
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R104
$6,000 per week
4 Beds
2.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Spacious with 2 living rooms and large bedrooms
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R112
$7,000 per week
4 Beds
2 Baths
Location:Bay side
One off the bay with great bay views
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R115
$6,000 per week
4 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Fully renovated and super comfortable
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty Exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R125
$7,000 per week
4 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Bay side
Beautiful house with great layout
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R128
$4,000 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Great upper deck space
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R033
$4,250 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Fully renovated immaculate cottage
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R032
$6,000 per week
3 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Bay side
One off the bay with bay views
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R019
$6,000 per week
3 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Ocean side
Amazing house 1 off ocean with spectacular views
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R061
$5,000 per week
4 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Charming spacious beach cottage
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R121
$7,000 per week
4 Beds
3 Baths
Location: Ocean side
Beautiful immaculate home 4th from the beach
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R129
$9,750 per week
4 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Ocean front
Fully renovated amazing house
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 Availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R037
$5,000 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Ocean side
6th from the ocean with private back deck
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R067
$4,000 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Bay side
Perfect beach house for relaxing
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R119
$4,750 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Bay side
Newly renovated with air conditioning
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty Exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R085
$4,000 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Bay side
Simple clean comfortable cottage
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R122
$4,250 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Bay side
Classic Fair Harbor cottage
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R127
$4,000 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Ocean side
Third from ocean with partial ocean view
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R005
$4,000 per week
3 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Bay side
Simple relaxing cottage
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R047
$3,000 per week
2 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Bay side
View Property
Property Status: Email for 2026 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Fair Harbor, Fire Island
Ref #: R009
$4,500 per week
2 Beds
1 Baths
Ocean Front
Open with vaulted ceiling
View Property