Why Rent with Newman Realty?
*William J. Newman Realty has over 40 years of experience in Fire Islands west end.
*We have 6 associates who are available 7 days a week to answer questions or help with any issues that arise during your stay.
*We offer free delivery of your luggage and freight when moving into your rental, making the move in process as easy as possible.
*Transparency-unlike most companies we show the price along with full details on all of our rental listings.
2 Bedrooms
Property Status:
Rented for 2025 Newman Realty Exclusive
Property Status:
Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R074
$3,500 per week
2 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Ocean side
Very spacious back deck area set up for great outside dining
Property Status:
Rented for 2024 Newman Realty exclusive
Property Status:
Rented for 2025 Newman Realty exclusive
3 Bedrooms / 1 Bath
Property Status:
Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R173
$4,000 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Bay side
Clean and comfortable cottage
Property Status:
Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R103
$4,900 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
1 off the beach with ocean views
Beautifully renovated and meticulously cared for
Property Status:
Email for 2024 availability
Ref #: R116
$4,000 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Bay side
New private expansive back deck
Property Status:
Rented for 2024 Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R037
$5,000 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Ocean side
6th from the ocean with private back deck
Property Status:
Rented for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R042
$4,000 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Bay side
1 off the bay with a great bay view
Property Status:
Email for 2024 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R067
$4,000 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Bay side
Perfect beach house for relaxing
Property Status:
Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R078
$3,500 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Bay side
Very private with oversized back deck
Property Status:
Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R119
$4,500 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Bay side
Newly renovated with air conditioning
Property Status:
Rented 2024
Ref #: R017
$3,500 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Ocean side
Clean and cozy beach side cottage
Property Status:
Rented for 2024 Newman Realty exclusive
Property Status:
Email for 2024 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R122
$4,000 per week
3 Beds
1 Baths
Location: Bay side
Classic Fair Harbor cottage
3 Bedrooms / 2 Baths
Property Status:
Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R172
$5,500 per week
3 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Bay Side
Well maintained and private
Property Status:
Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R171
$5,900 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Immaculate upside down house
Property Status:
Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R168
$4,500 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Steps to the beach and the bay
Clean and updated beach house
Property Status:
Email for 2024 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R166
$5,000 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Spacious 3 bedroom 1.5 bath
Open layout great for entertaining
Property Status:
Rented for 2024 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R163
$5,500 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Modernist gem designed by noted architect Horace Gifford
Property Status:
Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R162
$4,500 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Beautiful beach cottage very well maintained
Renovated kitchen and baths
Property Status:
Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R161
$6,000 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Amazing architectural house
Bay side on quiet walk
Property Status:
Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty Exclusive
Ref #: R044
$4,500 per week
3 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Bay side
Beautifully detailed and decorated
Property Status:
Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R158
$5,250 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Ocean front
Simple relaxing island living
Property Status:
Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R157
$4,500 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Renovated with new kitchen and bathrooms
Property Status:
Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty Exclusive
Ref #: R156
$4,000 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay Side
Clean and comfortable with AC
Property Status:
Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R155
$4,000 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Simple spacious beach cottage
Property Status:
Available 6/23-7/31 for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R149
$6,500 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Ocean front
Mid century modern with amazing views
Property Status:
Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Property Status:
Rented for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R139
$6,000 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: 1 off the beach with amazing ocean views
Triple mint fully renovated
Property Status:
Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty Exclusive
Ref #: R160
$5,600 per week
3 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Bay Front
Amazing views of the Great South Bay and Robert Moses Bridge
Property Status:
Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R128
$4,000 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Great upper deck space
Property Status:
Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R033
$4,250 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Fully renovated immaculate cottage
Property Status:
Rented for 2025 Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R027
$6,000 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Ocean side
4th from ocean exquisite house
Property Status:
Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R032
$6,000 per week
3 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Bay side
One off the bay with bay views
Property Status:
Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R019
$6,000 per week
3 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Ocean side
Amazing house 1 off ocean with spectacular views
Property Status:
Rented for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R058
$4,400 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Exquisite 2 bedroom with guest house
Property Status:
Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R127
$4,000 per week
3 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Ocean side
Third from ocean with partial ocean view
Property Status:
Email for 2024 availability Newman Realty exclusive
4 Bedrooms
Property Status:
Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R174
$6,500 per week
4 Beds
3 Baths
Location: 3rd from the beach
Beautiful and private just steps to the ocean
Property Status:
Rented for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R167
4 Beds
3.5 Baths
Ocean Front
Magnificent open layout with views from every room
Property Status:
Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R165
$7,000 per week
4 Beds
2.5 Baths
Beautiful fully renovated traditional beach house
Extremely private bay side location
Property Status:
Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R164
$5,500 per week
4 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay side close to the beach
Large open layout with vaulted ceilings
Property Status:
Rented for 2025 Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R159
$8,000 per week
4 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Ocean front
Beautiful house with rooftop deck and panoramic views
Property Status:
Rented for 2025 Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R153
$6,000 per week
4 Beds
2 Baths
Location: 1 off ocean
Mint ocean view cottage
Property Status:
Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty Exclusive
Property Status:
Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R146
$5,500 per week
4 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Ocean Side
Clean house on private property
Property Status:
Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R141
$9,000 per week
4 Beds
3 Baths
Location: Ocean front
Brand new construction triple mint full amenities
Property Status:
Emal for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R130
$6,000 per week
4 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
The perfect beach rental with every detail you could need
Property Status:
Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R086
$5,000 per week
4 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Bay side
Beautifully renovated beach home
Property Status:
Rented for 2025 Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R012
$6,500 per week
4 Beds
2.5 Baths
Location: Ocean side
4 houses from the ocean with ocean views from rooftop deck
Property Status:
Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R133
$6,500 per week
4 Beds
3.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Immaculate architectural house
Property Status:
Available June/September 2025 Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R024
$6,500 per week
4 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Ocean side
Great renovated house on quiet walk 6 from ocean
Property Status:
Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R049
$7,250 per week
4 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Bay front
Cove views from upper deck and sunset views
Property Status:
Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R051
$5,750 per week
4 Beds
2 Baths
Location: Bay side
Solid beach rental with everything you could need
Property Status:
Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R088
$5,000 per week
4 Beds
3 Baths
Location: Ocean side
Mint with 3 deck areas and close to the ocean
Property Status:
Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R097
$6,500 per week
4 Beds
2.5 Baths
Location: Bay front
Amazing water and sunset views
Property Status:
email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R104
$6,000 per week
4 Beds
2.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Spacious with 2 living rooms and large bedrooms
Property Status:
Rented for 2025 Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R115
$6,000 per week
4 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Fully renovated and super comfortable
Property Status:
Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R061
$5,000 per week
4 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Charming spacious beach cottage
Property Status:
Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R121
$7,000 per week
4 Beds
3 Baths
Location: Ocean side
Beautiful immaculate home 4th from the beach
Property Status:
Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R129
$9,000 per week
4 Beds
1.5 Baths
Location: Ocean front
Fully renovated amazing house
5+ Bedrooms
Property Status:
Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R170
$10,000 per week
5 Beds
2.5 Baths
Location: Bay Front
Amazing bay and sunset views
Property Status:
Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R169
$5,000 per week
5 Beds
2 Baths
Location Bay Side
Spacious beach house with renovated kitchen
Property Status:
Email for 2025 availability Newman Realty Exclusive
Ref #: R154
$6,000 per week
5 Beds
2.5 Baths
Location: Close to the ocean
Beautifully renovated 5 bedroom
Property Status:
Rented for 2025 Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R015
$7,500 per week
5 Beds
2.5 Baths
Location: Bay side with bay views
Triple mint new construction
Property Status:
Rented for 2025 availability Newman Realty exclusive
Ref #: R021
$7,250 per week
5 Beds
2.5 Baths
Location: Bay side
Pristine secluded beach house